Hormuz Tanker Freight Hits $27 a Barrel, but Owners Book at $3.50

The Baltic benchmark prices the next Gulf-to-China supertanker voyage. Owners' bookings, mostly fixed before the September spike, price the same trip at an eighth of that. Fourth-quarter bookings will show which number shareholders collect.

Brent traded at $100.40 a barrel on September 23, up about 1% but near two-week lows, after Saudi Arabia restarted its East-West pipeline to the Red Sea on Tuesday. On the crude screen, the Strait of Hormuz disruption is easing. The tanker market says otherwise. In the week to September 18, the Baltic Exchange's TD3C benchmark for a 270,000-tonne VLCC from the Middle East Gulf to China reached a round-trip time-charter equivalent of $1.21 million a day. TD34, the Gulf of Oman-to-China route that avoids a Hormuz transit, was near $871,000 a day.

A 270,000-tonne cargo is about 2 million barrels. On a 45-day round trip, $1.21 million a day comes to about $54.5 million, or roughly $27 a barrel. TCE is struck after bunkers and port costs, so the charterer's gross freight bill is higher still. The same arithmetic puts TD34 at about $19.60 a barrel. The difference, roughly $7.60, is approximately what the market charges for loading inside the strait rather than outside it.

Two prices for the same ship

The $27 is a marginal price: what an owner earns on a cargo fixed at this week's assessment. The fleet earns far less.

When Frontline reported second-quarter results on August 28, it had booked 86% of its third-quarter VLCC spot days at $156,900 a day. On the same assumptions, that is about $7.1 million a voyage, or roughly $3.50 a barrel. DHT's August 5 results showed 58% of its third-quarter spot days booked at $152,700 a day, about $3.45 a barrel. Two owners, one conclusion: the fleet's booked quarter prices the trip at an eighth of the benchmark.

Timing explains most of the gap. Those bookings were largely made in July and August. The spike came after a drone strike on September 10 forced the East-West pipeline to shut from September 11, removing the main bypass for Saudi crude and pushing more buyers toward the few vessels willing to load inside the Gulf. Frontline had also warned that ballast days would pull its full-quarter spot TCE below the contracted figure.

Thin trading explains the rest. During a partial closure, TD3C probably sees few fixtures, and a handful of cargoes fixed at extreme war-risk premiums can set the assessment while most of the fleet trades on other routes, older fixtures or period charters. The benchmark's reliability is already contested in court: Mercuria is suing the Baltic Exchange, arguing that TD3C stopped reflecting the market once the war disrupted the route. The Exchange says lawful shipping through the strait remained possible and its panel kept reflecting market reality. A 15-day trial opens in London's High Court on October 26.

So $27 is the right number for a refiner pricing a prompt replacement cargo and the wrong one for an investor valuing a tanker company. The refiner pays close to the marginal rate. The shareholder collects the blended rate, which for now is dominated by fixtures agreed before the spike.

CTOL view: We expect Frontline's fourth-quarter VLCC spot bookings, which it discloses with third-quarter results in late November, to average between $175,000 and $250,000 a day. That is above the third quarter's $156,900 but less than a quarter of the TD3C peak. At $200,000 a day, booked earnings would be about $4.50 a barrel. Our reasoning is sequencing: the pipeline restart and Iran's reopening talk arrived before most October and November voyages were fixed, and marginal freight falls faster than it rises. Frontline publishes this booked-rate figure every quarter. We are wrong if the rate it reports for fourth-quarter VLCC spot bookings is below $175,000 or above $250,000 a day.

What reaches the income statement

Even the booked rate is extraordinary. Frontline's $156,900 is about 6.6 times its VLCC cash breakeven of $23,800 a day, which converts to about 54 cents a barrel. DHT says its spot breakeven for the third quarter is negative, because fixed-rate charter income already exceeds forecast operating costs. Frontline posted its best quarterly profit ever in the second quarter, $659.2 million, on a VLCC spot TCE of $152,700 a day. It has also locked in part of the upcycle, fixing two newbuildings on one-year charters at $120,000 a day and two older VLCCs for two and three years at $90,000 and $75,000.

If owners fix a meaningful share of October and November voyages at even a third of TD3C, per-day VLCC earnings would more than double from the third quarter. If the pipeline restart and diplomacy compress the benchmark first, owners will mostly have watched the spike from the sidelines.

The stock gives no verdict yet. Frontline was down 1.1% at $47.40 at 12:24pm in New York, a move too small to read as a view on the fourth quarter.

Where the vessel-days go

The freight spike is about time more than crude. Every day a tanker spends waiting for war-risk cover, shuttling crude to a safer loading point, completing a ship-to-ship transfer or sailing a longer route is a day of transport capacity lost, even though the fleet has not shrunk. With Yanbu cut off from its main feed for eleven days, Saudi barrels that had been leaving through the Red Sea had to go through the Gulf or stay in the ground.

Refiners carry the other side. A replacement barrel from West Africa or the Americas solves the availability problem but ties up inventory and working capital for longer and arrives at a higher delivered cost. The strain shows downstream: European diesel cracks reached a record of about $95 a barrel over Brent this week, after President Trump backed a possible US diesel export ban. With diesel margins at a record while crude trades near two-week lows, the bottleneck is logistics and refining, not crude supply.

What unwinds it

Three developments would shrink the marginal rate. The pipeline is the first: a sustained restart takes Saudi exports off Gulf-loading tankers. The second is the strait itself. An Iranian official said this week that Hormuz could reopen within seven days if the United States eased military pressure and lifted its blockade of Iranian ports. The third is insurance. Once owners accept Gulf voyages without extraordinary war-risk premiums, waiting and shuttle days fall and the same fleet moves more barrels.

Freight can fall far faster than supply can rise, because it prices idle days rather than new barrels. A credible reopening could strip much of the TD3C premium out within weeks, while period charters at $75,000 to $120,000 a day would keep owners' earnings elevated well into 2027. For Asian refiners, the freight curve and war-risk terms now matter at least as much as the next $5 move in Brent.

Hormuz Tanker Freight Hits $27 a Barrel, but Owners Book at $3.50

Two prices for the same ship

What reaches the income statement

Where the vessel-days go

What unwinds it

Sources

You May Also Like

Subscribe to our Newsletter