SoftBank’s 62% Fall: Arm Drove 90% of Pro Forma NAV Loss Since 30 June 2026, Discount Widened

By
CTOL Staff Reporter
1 min read

Arm accounted for about 90% of the JPY 27.6 trillion pro forma NAV loss after 30 June 2026; a widening discount explains the additional share price decline.

Tokyo Stock Exchange closing prices put SoftBank at JPY 3,281 on 17 November 2026, down 62.0% from JPY 8,632 on 2 June 2026. By 30 June 2026, shares had fallen 30.9%, from JPY 8,632 on 2 June 2026 to JPY 5,963, while reported NAV stood at a record JPY 72.3 trillion. The Wall Street Journal tied it to Nvidia's AI selloff (17 November 2026 coverage). We would pass: the 62% headline combines an early fall with a later widening discount.

From JPY 5,963 on 30 June 2026 to JPY 3,281 on 17 November 2026, shares fell 45.0%. Pro forma NAV fell 38.2%, from JPY 72.3 trillion to JPY 44.7 trillion at 9 November 2026 prices (SoftBank's Q2 FY2026 presentation). Arm's NAV slice fell from JPY 43.4 trillion on 30 June 2026 to JPY 18.6 trillion at 9 November 2026 prices, losing JPY 24.8 trillion. We calculate 89.9% of the total NAV decline (JPY 24.8 trillion / JPY 27.6 trillion). Arm (54%) and OpenAI (21%) made up 75% of holdings' equity value at 30 September 2026. Capital Conversion is the gap between NAV and shareholder value when management cannot turn holdings into cash, debt reduction or fewer shares. We attribute the first repricing to asset losses; the widening discount explains the additional decline.

Reported LTV rose from 13.0% on 30 June 2026 to 15.9% on 30 September 2026. Holding 30 September 2026 net debt at JPY 11.3 trillion constant, our pro forma LTV estimate at 9 November 2026 prices is 20.2%: JPY 11.3 trillion / (JPY 44.7 trillion + JPY 11.3 trillion). As of Q2 FY2026, SoftBank's normal LTV ceiling is 25%, our assumed financing limit; cash was JPY 5.0 trillion at 30 September 2026. Our reading is that leverage amplifies the asset shock, despite LTV remaining below policy.

At 30 September 2026, SoftBank's Q2 FY2026 financial report valued the OpenAI holding at USD 99.6 billion against USD 54.6 billion invested; the mark was unchanged since 31 March 2026. After a further USD 10.0 billion on 1 October 2026, cumulative investment reached USD 64.6 billion and ownership about 13%. At the 17 November 2026 close, JPY 3,281 × 5,699,306,663 shares (30 September 2026 count) = JPY 18.7 trillion market capitalization, or USD 118 billion at the 9 November 2026 rate of JPY 158.34 per dollar. The OpenAI mark equalled 84% of that value (USD 99.6 billion / USD 118 billion). We distinguish the private mark, which supports NAV, from sales, debt reduction or repurchases that reach shareholders.

SoftBank's bullish case rests on a potential Q3 revaluation. CNBC reported SoftBank's Q3 valuation case on 10 November 2026. The company said an updated OpenAI valuation "could be reflected in the fiscal third quarter, potentially boosting its net asset value" (CNBC). At 30 September 2026, USD 99.6 billion / USD 54.6 billion = 1.82x. Cash was JPY 5.0 trillion, and our 20.2% pro forma LTV estimate remained below the normal ceiling. No margin call trigger was disclosed. A new funding round could lift NAV and reduce Q3 LTV before any sale or repurchase, giving shares a route to recover.

Tokyo Stock Exchange closing prices show shares fell 48.6%, from JPY 6,828.75 on 29 October 2025 to JPY 3,507 on 23 March 2026; SoftBank reported 20.6% LTV at 31 December 2025. They then rose 146% to JPY 8,632 by 2 June 2026. LTV near 20% did not prevent a powerful recovery. Today's issue is whether a higher private mark reaches shareholders as cash or fewer shares. We treat the rebound as price evidence alone; capital allocation remains a separate decision.

In a scenario, a 20% increase on the USD 99.6 billion OpenAI fair value at 30 September 2026 adds USD 19.9 billion (0.2 × USD 99.6 billion), or about JPY 3.15 trillion at the 9 November 2026 rate of JPY 158.34 per dollar. That is 7.1% of JPY 44.7 trillion pro forma NAV at 9 November 2026 prices (JPY 3.15 trillion / JPY 44.7 trillion). It moves our pro forma LTV estimate from 20.2% to about 19.1% (JPY 11.3 trillion / (JPY 56.0 trillion + JPY 3.15 trillion)). The mark improves the balance sheet but adds no shareholder cash or treasury stock purchases.

SoftBank purchased JPY 3 million of treasury stock in H1 FY2026, against JPY 93.2 billion in H1 FY2025, according to the financing section of its Q2 FY2026 financial report. Cash and LTV headroom remain, yet the mechanism that increases each remaining shareholder's claim has nearly disappeared. Our 17 November 2026 market capitalization to pro forma NAV ratio is 0.42x, using NAV at 9 November 2026 prices (JPY 18.7 trillion / JPY 44.7 trillion). Arm and Intel have fallen since 9 November 2026, so the live ratio is higher. The ratio is a snapshot; buybacks record capital returned.

On 23 March 2020, SoftBank said its shares traded at a 73% discount to intrinsic value as of the end of the previous week, the largest in history. Its board authorized up to JPY 4.5 trillion of asset sales or monetization. It also authorized up to JPY 2 trillion of common stock repurchases over four quarters, alongside a JPY 500 billion programme announced on 13 March 2020. The 23 March 2020 company release records authorization; it gives no execution total. SoftBank's 73% figure was its intrinsic value discount; today's 0.42x compares market capitalization with pro forma NAV at 9 November 2026 prices. OpenAI is unlisted, so monetizing it requires a transaction. Management once authorized asset sales and repurchases to address a discount.

SoftBank shares are a claim on the portfolio. You benefit from an OpenAI revaluation only when value reaches the company and strengthens your claim. Cash covers bond redemptions and investment; debt reduction lowers financing risk; repurchases shrink the share count. Those uses compete for balance sheet capacity; NAV alone cannot tell you which management will choose.

SoftBank's Q2 FY2026 earnings presentation sets a policy to keep at least two years of bond redemptions in cash. Our Capital Conversion framework turns on that allocation: liquidity is protected, while H1 purchases remain minimal.

CTOL would continue to pass at the current price until management demonstrates that reported NAV can become shareholder value. The capital-conversion explanation would be wrong if, at the Q3 FY2026 report for the quarter ended 31 December 2026, cumulative treasury-stock purchases reach at least JPY 93.2 billion, our chosen threshold equal to the H1 FY2025 six-month figure, while the market-cap-to-pro-forma-NAV ratio remains at or below the current 0.42x benchmark.

You May Also Like

This article is submitted by our user under the News Submission Rules and Guidelines. The cover photo is computer generated art for illustrative purposes only; not indicative of factual content. If you believe this article infringes upon copyright rights, please do not hesitate to report it by sending an email to us. Your vigilance and cooperation are invaluable in helping us maintain a respectful and legally compliant community.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Get the latest in enterprise business and tech with exclusive peeks at our new offerings

We use cookies on our website to enable certain functions, to provide more relevant information to you and to optimize your experience on our website. Further information can be found in our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Service . Mandatory information can be found in the legal notice