Target and Lowe's Q3: Target Gained 68 Basis Points of Margin Excluding Tariff Refunds
Both retailers posted strong Q3 results, but tariff refunds complicate the consumer resilience story. Target improved margins and EPS excluding refunds, while Lowe's refund neutral margin declined. Target faces a 4.8% fourth-quarter test.
Target earned $2.65 a share in its third quarter, but 50 cents arrived without a customer walking through the door. It came from $301 million in tariff refunds, booked as lower cost of sales. Lowe's recognized roughly $250 million from the same duty refunds and made a different choice: spend about one third immediately on customer value, and commit the rest for the fourth quarter. The better earnings will matter only if shoppers and margins cooperate when refunds stop.
We would favor Target's operating recovery over Lowe's refund-supported earnings, provided Target's margins hold. Target gained 68 basis points of operating margin excluding refunds; Lowe's, after allowance for customer spending funded by its refund, lost roughly 140. Refund-Neutral Leverage is the operating margin remaining after deducting tariff refunds and reversing customer investments financed with them. Target has a recovery to defend; Lowe's has a customer investment to justify. We expect Target's fourth-quarter adjusted operating margin excluding refunds to stay above 4.8%, its prior-year rate.
Target's filing supplies an unusually clean subtraction. Operating income of $1,672 million less the $301 million refund leaves $1,371 million over $27,067 million in sales, or 5.07%. A year earlier, adjusted operating income of $1,109 million over $25,270 million gave 4.39%. The gain is 68 basis points. Adjusted EPS of $2.65 less the $0.50 refund was $2.15 against $1.78, about 21% higher. Customs did not supply that underlying profit growth.
Lowe's needs one extra adjustment. Its operating figures put adjusted income at $2,671 million. Subtracting roughly $250 million in refunds leaves $2,421 million over $22,756 million in sales, or 10.64%, against 12.41% a year ago. But roughly $83 million, one third of the refund, funded customer value. Adding it back gives $2,504 million over $22,756 million, about 11.0%, still 140 basis points below last year. Adjusted EPS of $3.10 less its $0.34 refund was $2.76 against $3.06. Customer investment deserves a fair accounting; it still has to earn a return.
The sales lines help explain why the companies spend differently. Target's comparable sales rose 5.6%, backed by 5.0% more traffic and 9.8% digital growth. Lowe's comparable sales rose 1.8%, with average ticket up 3.5% and transactions down 1.7%. Its total sales increased 9.3%, aided by FBM and ADG acquisitions. Online grew 17.4%. Online growth is worth defending, but fewer transactions leave the investment needing a return.
Lowe's CFO Brandon Sink gave the opposing case on the earnings call: "So really it's net neutral on the year." He said about one third of the refund went into customer value in Q3, with the rest committed to Q4. On the 2026 horizon, the $250 million finances a more competitive offer without reducing full-year adjusted EPS guidance. Online sales growth of 17.4% makes protecting repeat business a plausible investment. Lowe's is buying customer demand instead of booking the entire refund as profit.
Full-year guidance offers two tests on Lowe's own horizon. Adjusted EPS stays at $12.25 even as the sales outlook rises from $92.0 billion to $92.5 billion; adjusted operating margin guidance falls from 11.6% to 11.5%. The implied fourth quarter is revealing: $12.25 less quarterly adjusted EPS of $3.03, $4.40 and $3.10 implies $1.72, against $1.98 a year earlier. Reinvesting two thirds of $250 million costs roughly $167 million pretax, or about $0.22 a share after 24.5% tax across 561.4 million shares. Without that fourth-quarter spending, implied EPS would be $1.94. Sink's timing explanation works, but stronger annual sales still buy less margin.
There is an uncomfortable precedent inside Target's own history. Adjusted operating margin slid from 5.2% in FY2024 to 4.6% in FY2025, and adjusted EPS fell from $8.86 to $7.57. Comparable sales declined 2.7% in Q3 2025 and 2.5% in Q4. A recovery in retail margins can vanish with a weaker sales comparison. This year is different in an important respect: Target's Q3 traffic rose 5.0%, and its EPS excluding refunds increased about 21%. That makes today's gain more than an accounting benefit, while durability remains open.
Target itself supplies the other caution. Its release attributes part of roughly 1.2 percentage points of gross margin improvement excluding refunds to lapping elevated markdowns and tariff rates. CFO Jim Lee said on the earnings call: "Excluding tariff refunds, adjusted operating income increased 24% in the quarter". Target's full-year adjusted EPS guidance of $10.65 to $11.40 includes $2.14 from recognized refunds, leaving $8.51 to $9.26 without them, above March's $7.50 to $8.50 range. Yet FY2025's 4.6% adjusted margin plus management's expected 0.5-point improvement gives about 5.1% without refunds, below FY2024's 5.2%. We would price a cyclical recovery rather than a permanently higher margin.
Tariff refunds run on a legal timetable separate from the retail calendar. Customs and Border Protection says valid IEEPA refunds are generally issued within 60 to 90 days after acceptance of a declaration, through a phased process. Target already recognized $1.3 billion pretax in nine months, adding about 1.6 percentage points to its nine-month operating margin. Lowe's Q2 adjusted EPS carried another $0.11 of refund benefit before Q3's $0.34, while its August and November full-year EPS outlooks both stood at $12.25. The legal recovery belongs outside recurring store profitability.
Census advance sales released 17 November 2026 rose 6.8% in October from a year earlier, measured in nominal dollars. From August through October, general merchandise stores grew 4.2% and building material and garden equipment dealers 5.0%. Different store mixes limit the comparison, while Refund-Neutral Leverage forces the argument back to each chain's margin. If Lowe's value spending brings transactions back, competitors face pressure to match it. If it fails, the spending sacrifices margin without restoring transactions.
We would allocate toward Target's underlying earnings recovery ahead of Lowe's hoped-for margin rebound, without paying for another round of tariff refunds. We would be wrong about Target's continuing improvement if its fiscal fourth-quarter 2026 results, checked by 31 March 2027, show adjusted operating margin excluding refunds below the 4.8% adjusted rate of the fourth quarter of 2025.